What Ethics is Not | UPSC Ethics Notes (GS Paper IV)
Introduction
To understand ethics clearly, it is equally important to know what ethics is not. Ethics is often confused with morality, values, social norms, religion, or law. However, ethics differs from each of them in its universality, reasoning, and objective nature.
1. Ethics is Not Morality
Morality refers to an individual’s or group’s own standards of judging right and wrong, which may differ across people, cultures, or time periods.
Ethics, on the other hand, deals with universal standards of human conduct applicable to all.
Key Differences Between Ethics and Morality
| Ground of Difference | Ethics | Morality |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | Universal standards of human behavior | Individual or societal standards of behavior |
| Dependent on | Others’ perspective (universal view) | One’s personal or cultural perspective |
| Consistency | Uniform across humanity | Varies person to person, society to society |
| Religious Connotation | Largely secular and reason-based | Often linked to faith or custom |
| Root Word | Ethos = Character | Moralis = Customs/Traditions |
Example:
Removing “ghunghat” among rural women shows change in moral values with time, while ethical standards like respect and dignity remain universal.
Why One Should Be Moral
- To attain Summum Bonum – the highest good or ultimate happiness.
- Prevents guilt, anxiety, or social disapproval.
- Promotes rational, harmonious living within society.
2. Ethics is Not Values
Values are personal or societal standards of what is considered important or desirable. They vary across individuals and cultures.
Ethics, however, is based on universal human values that promote collective well-being.
Example:
Following caste rules may be a value for some, but it is not ethical, as it violates equality and human dignity.
Key Point:
- Ethics is based on values, but not all values are ethical.
3. Ethics is Not Social Norms
Social norms are customs and traditions specific to a society.
They dictate acceptable behavior within that community but lack universality.
Example:
Touching elders’ feet may be a social norm in India, while respect for elders is an ethical value across cultures.
In short:
- Social norms = community-based expectations.
- Ethics = universal moral principles.
4. Ethics is Not Religion
Religion is based on faith, beliefs, and divine authority, often within a particular community.
Ethics, however, is based on reason, logic, and universality.
Comparison:
| Aspect | Religion | Ethics |
|---|---|---|
| Basis | Faith, divine command | Reason, rationality |
| Scope | Specific to religion/community | Universal and secular |
| Reasoning | Limited questioning | Open to critical inquiry |
| Universality | Varies by religion | Same for all humans |
However, ethics draws inspiration from religion.
For example:
| Religion | Ethical Values Derived |
|---|---|
| Christianity | Compassion, forgiveness |
| Jainism | Ahimsa, Satya, Aparigraha |
| Buddhism | The Middle Path, Self-enlightenment (Appo Deepo Bhava) |
| Hinduism | Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, Nishkam Karma, Truth (Satyameva Jayate) |
| Islam | Equality, brotherhood |
5. Ethics is Not Law
Law refers to the rules and regulations enforced by the state.
Ethics, in contrast, refers to moral standards that guide what ought to be done, even beyond legal compulsion.
Example:
Law may permit certain actions (like animal testing), but ethically, it can still be questioned on moral grounds.
Key Differences Between Law and Ethics
| Aspect | Law | Ethics |
|---|---|---|
| Basis | Enforced by the state | Guided by conscience and reasoning |
| Scope | Specific to a society | Universal |
| Penalty | Legal punishment | Social or moral disapproval |
| Nature | External control | Internal control |
Relation Between Law and Ethics
Generally, law and ethics work together to maintain order and justice.
However, conflicts may arise:
- Civil Servant’s Role: Should follow the law for legal protection and institutional discipline.
- Social Reformer’s Role: Should prioritize ethics to challenge unjust laws and promote change (e.g., Mahatma Gandhi’s civil disobedience).
Conclusion
Ethics stands distinct from morality, values, religion, social norms, and law.
While all these influence human behavior, ethics provides the universal, rational, and reason-based foundation upon which a just and moral society can be built.
| Not Ethics | Reason |
|---|---|
| Morality | Individual and culture-specific |
| Values | Vary person to person |
| Social Norms | Custom-based, not universal |
| Religion | Based on faith, not reason |
| Law | Enforced externally, not moral obligation |
FAQs on “What Ethics is Not”
1. Is ethics the same as morality?
No. Morality is personal or societal, while ethics is universal and rational.
2. Can a value be unethical?
Yes. Example: Following caste rules may be a value but is unethical as it promotes discrimination.
3. Are all religious teachings ethical?
Not necessarily. While religion inspires ethics, some practices may contradict universal moral principles.
4. What if law and ethics conflict?
A civil servant must follow the law; a reformer may challenge it ethically to bring social change.
5. Why is ethics superior to social norms?
Because ethics applies universally, while social norms change across cultures.
Tags: UPSC Ethics Notes, GS Paper 4, Ethics vs Morality, Ethics vs Religion, Ethics and Law, UPSC Study Material, Civil Services Ethics