Q : Suppose the Government of India is thinking of constructing a dam in a mountain valley bound by forests and inhabited by ethnic communities. What rational policy should it resort to in dealing with unforeseen contingencies?
Introduction
Development projects such as dams are vital for energy generation, irrigation, and regional growth. However, when proposed in ecologically fragile and culturally sensitive areas, they often lead to ethical, environmental, and social dilemmas. Hence, a rational and ethical policy framework is needed to balance development with justice, ecology, and human rights.
Ethical Dimensions Involved
- Utilitarian Ethics: Maximizing overall welfare while minimizing harm.
- Environmental Ethics: Protecting biodiversity and ecological integrity.
- Justice and Fairness: Ensuring equitable treatment and compensation for affected communities.
- Procedural Ethics: Ensuring transparency, participation, and accountability in decision-making.
Rational Policy to Deal with Unforeseen Contingencies
| Stage | Policy Measures | Ethical Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Pre-construction (Planning) | Conduct comprehensive Environmental and Social Impact Assessments (EIA & SIA), including disaster vulnerability mapping. | Informed and responsible decision-making. |
| 2. Community Consultation | Ensure Free, Prior, and Informed Consent (FPIC) of ethnic communities; include them in planning and benefit-sharing. | Respect for autonomy and cultural rights. |
| 3. Risk Mitigation Mechanism | Create Disaster Management Plans, biodiversity offsets, and early warning systems. | Precautionary and preventive ethics. |
| 4. Compensation and Rehabilitation | Fair and transparent Resettlement & Rehabilitation (R&R) packages; livelihood restoration. | Distributive justice and human dignity. |
| 5. Monitoring and Redressal | Establish independent oversight bodies and grievance redressal systems for continuous review. | Accountability and responsiveness. |
| 6. Adaptive Governance | Maintain flexible policy frameworks to modify plans in case of natural, social, or environmental contingencies. | Ethical prudence and adaptability. |
Way Forward
- Adopt a Sustainable Human Development Model rather than a purely economic one.
- Encourage participatory governance and local stewardship in environmental decisions.
- Integrate traditional ecological knowledge of ethnic communities with modern science.
Conclusion
A truly rational policy is one that harmonizes development with dignity, progress with prudence, and growth with sustainability. By embedding ethics, transparency, and inclusivity in its decision-making, the government can ensure that the dam becomes a symbol of balanced progress, not a cause of irreversible loss.
Other Posts which Might U like ,
Tags
ETHICS PYQs